Skip to main content

reforming health care at the state level

This keeps coming back to me: federal level health care reform is stalled, related to massive dysfunction in the legislative branch of government in Washington D.C.  Add to that the fact that we have a huge and incredibly diverse country, and it is not too surprising that we haven’t come up with an acceptable health care reform bill.

But what about Massachusetts? They managed to pass health care reform, and though it is not perfect, it beats the heck out of what they have in Washington and Idaho, the states in which I practice medicine.
Just today I read an article in the New England Journal of Medicine about the way the medicaid system is administered in Oregon. They use cost effectiveness research to determine a basic health care package, and then budget to allow as many people as possible to be covered by the state Medicaid system.  This is the article: http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/full/362/7/e18

I would very much like to see Idaho, where we spend 20% of our state budget on health care, combine intelligent “rationing” with creative payment schemes (prepaid health care aimed at encouraging appropriate health care utilization) to extend coverage to state residents who can’t afford to pay for private insurance.
In fact I would very much like to see every state design location appropriate health care reform to take care of citizens who don’t have access. The huge crisis of medicare costs still needs to be dealt with at a federal level because medicare is a federal program and is much of the federal budget. Much of the house health care bill focused on making medicare more efficient and more effective. Reciprocity would also be an issue if health care reform was done by the states, but that is hardly a deal breaker.

Comments

Kevin Carson said…
I couldn't find a contact email for your blog, so I decided to ask you a question in the comment.

The other day I saw Sanjay Gupta talking about a bag of saline that cost almost $300, an incision stapler that cost hundreds of dollars, and so on.

I'd like to know why this stuff is so expensive.

Given the institutional culture of hospitals, I'm sure it's probably the same kind of cost-plus markup that leads to $600 toilet seats at military contractors. I wonder, in particular, if patents and proprietary design standards interact with government mandated product specifications to prevent cost competition.

In a field I'm more familiar with, machine tools, I've seen open-source hardware hackers come up with homebrew CNC routers, cutting tables, 3-D printers, lathes, etc., that can be built for a few hundred dollars--compared to tens of thousands of dollars for commercial versions with proprietary designs. Simply stripping prices of rents on "intellectual property," and resorting to expedients like modular design for ease of repair, can result in a Factor Twenty cost reduction.

Can you suggest any leads on the mechanisms that are responsible for the high cost of medical supplies and equipment? What, exactly, is protecting them from competition, or imposing entry barriers?
Janice Boughton said…
I think it's the unintended results of insurance billing. The costs of things in medicine are based on what insurance can be expected to pay, and they are never billed lower than what the highest payer will pay. The billed amounts do not have much to do with the actual value of the good or services. I don't know how the bag of saline got to be $300, and I bet that most insurance payers will not pay that much for it. Unfortunately, because it is billed at the highest imaginable cost, that will be the bill that an uninsured patient will see and they will not have a contractual adjustment like the insurance companies do to automatically lower that cost.

Many medical goods an services, including medications and office visits could actually be provided for very affordable fees. See Walmart's $4 plans for basic medicines and my $25 plan. Neither of these are based on charity. The products just aren't that expensive when the barrier of insurance payments is removed from the picture.

Popular posts from this blog

How to make your own ultrasound gel (which is also sterile and edible and environmentally friendly) **UPDATED--NEW RECIPE**

I have been doing lots of bedside ultrasound lately and realized how useful it would be in areas far off the beaten track like Haiti, for instance. With a bedside ultrasound (mine fits in my pocket) I could diagnose heart disease, kidney and gallbladder problems, various cancers as well as lung and intestinal diseases. Then I realized that I would have to take a whole bunch of ultrasound gel with me which would mean that I would have to check luggage, which is a real pain when traveling light to a place where luggage disappears. I heard that you can use water, or spit, in a pinch, or even lotion, though oil based coupling media apparently break down the surface of the transducer. Or, of course, you can just use ultrasound gel. Ultrasound requires an aqueous interface between the transducer and the skin or else all you see is black. Ultrasound gel is a clear goo, looks like hair gel or aloe vera, and is made by several companies out of various combinations of propylene glycol, glyce

Ivermectin for Covid--Does it work? We don't know.

  Lately there has been quite a heated controversy about whether to use ivermectin for Covid-19.  The FDA , a US federal agency responsible for providing unbiased information to protect people from harmful drugs, foods, even tobacco products, has said that there is not good evidence of ivermectin's safety and effectiveness in treating Covid 19, and that just about sums up what we truly know about ivermectin in the context of Covid. The CDC, Centers for Disease Control, a branch of the department of Health and Human Services, tasked with preventing and treating disease and injury, also recently warned  people not to use ivermectin to treat Covid outside of actual clinical trials. Certain highly qualified physicians, including ones who practice critical care medicine and manage many patients with severe Covid infections in the intensive care unit vocally support the use of ivermectin to treat Covid and have published dosing schedules and reviews of the literature supporting it for tr

Old Fangak, South Sudan--Bedside Ultrasound and other stuff

I just got back from a couple of weeks in Old Fangak, a community of people living by the Zaraf River in South Sudan. It's normally a small community, with an open market and people who live by raising cows, trading on the river, fishing and gardening. Now there are tens of thousands of people there, still displaced from their homes by the civil war which has gone on intermittently for decades. There are even more people now than there were last year. There is a hospital in Old Fangak, which is run by Jill Seaman, one of the founders of Sudan Medical relief and a fierce advocate for treatment of various horrible and neglected tropical diseases, along with some very skilled and committed local clinical officers and nurses and a contingent of doctors, nurses and support staff from Medecins Sans Frontieres (Doctors Without Borders, also known as MSF) who have been helping out for a little over a year. The hospital attempts to do a lot with a little, and treats all who present ther